The 10 Best Christmas Cookies Your Family Will Beg For All Year • THE ENDEARING DESIGNER

Skip the flour-dusted counters and marathon baking sessions this holiday season. You’re juggling gift shopping, holiday parties, and family gatherings—the last thing you need is spending hours in the kitchen trying to perfect homemade Christmas cookies.

Here’s the good news: you can serve bakery-quality Christmas cookies that taste like they came straight from grandma’s oven without turning on your mixer once. We’ve tested and reviewed the 10 best Christmas cookies available on Amazon, so you can spend less time baking and more time enjoying the holidays with your loved ones.

1. Michel & Augustin Chocolate Butter Squares

Michel et Augustin Christmas Cookies [click to view…]

French pastry perfection meets American convenience with these buttery shortbread squares. Each cookie features a crispy butter cookie exterior filled with rich chocolate ganache in the center.

Why your family will love them:

Made in France with real butter and premium ingredients
Dark chocolate and sea salt flavor creates the perfect sweet-salty balance
No preservatives, GMOs, or artificial flavors
Individually wrapped for freshness

Michel et Augustin Christmas Cookies [click to view…]

These cookies bring authentic French pâtisserie quality to your holiday table. The butter content gives them a melt-in-your-mouth texture that rivals anything you’d bake at home. Perfect for afternoon tea, coffee breaks, or as an after-dinner treat.

Best for: Adults who appreciate gourmet flavors and European-style cookies

2. David’s Cookies Winter Wonderland Assortment

David’s Cookies Christmas Cookies [click to view…]

This festive tin delivers variety and quality in one beautiful package. You get 24 fresh-baked cookies in three popular flavors: Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Chip, and Red Velvet.

What makes them special:

Baked the same day they ship
Golden-brown exterior with soft, chewy centers
Whimsical holiday tin design
Kosher OU-D certified

David’s Cookies has been perfecting their recipes for decades, and it shows. These cookies taste homemade because they follow traditional baking methods without shortcuts. The White Chocolate Chip cookies are particularly popular with kids, while adults tend to gravitate toward the sophisticated Red Velvet flavor.

Best for: Families who want variety and those shopping for gifts

3. Cheryl’s Cookies Holiday Gift Tin

Cheryl’s Cookies® Bow Gift Box [click to view…]

Cheryl’s has built a reputation since 1981 for their buttercream-frosted cut-out cookies, and their holiday assortment lives up to the hype.

What’s inside:

16 buttercream frosted cut-out cookies
Traditional holiday shapes (stars, trees, ornaments)
Snickerdoodle and gingerbread varieties
Decorative holiday tin packaging

These cookies are what Christmas looks like. The buttercream frosting is smooth and sweet without being overwhelming, and the shortbread base provides the perfect foundation. They’re visually stunning on any cookie platter.

Best for: Traditional cookie lovers and Instagram-worthy holiday spreads

4. David’s Cookies Butter Pecan Meltaways

David’s Cookies Butter Pecan Meltaways [click to view…]

If you’ve never tried a meltaway cookie, prepare yourself. These crumbly, tender cookies literally dissolve on your tongue.

The details:

Made with pure creamy butter and large pecan chunks
Dusted with powdered sugar
Approximately 60 cookies per tin
120-day shelf life

The pecan pieces add a satisfying crunch to contrast with the delicate cookie base. The powdered sugar coating gives them an elegant, finished look that makes them perfect for gift-giving. One customer review noted: “These cookies have a superb texture which crumbles and melts in your mouth.”

Best for: Nut lovers and those who prefer delicate, sophisticated cookies

5. Wicklein Original Nürnberger Lebkuchen

German Cookies [click to view…]

Transport your holiday table to a German Christmas market with these authentic gingerbread cookies. Wicklein has been baking Nuremberg lebkuchen since 1615—that’s over 400 years of perfecting their craft.

What sets them apart:

Authentic German recipe with 14% nuts and kernels
Glazed oblaten-style on a wafer base
Fair Trade certified
Free from artificial flavors and colors

Lebkuchen differs from American gingerbread cookies. They’re softer, more cake-like, and packed with spices. The nut content (almonds, hazelnuts, and walnuts must comprise 50% of the nut mixture) gives them a richer flavor than typical gingerbread. Serve them with coffee or hot chocolate for an authentic European experience.

Best for: Adventurous eaters and those seeking authentic international holiday traditions

6. Christmas Fortune Cookies

4E’s Novelty Christmas Fortune Cookies [click to view…]

Add an unexpected twist to your holiday celebrations with these festive fortune cookies. Each of the 50 cookies is individually wrapped in red and green packaging.

Why they’re fun:

Classic vanilla flavor
Cheerful holiday-themed fortunes inside
Perfect for party favors or stocking stuffers
Nut-free and bakery-fresh

Kids love cracking these open to read their fortunes, and adults appreciate the novelty. They’re crisp and sweet without being overwhelming. Use them as place settings at your holiday dinner, add them to gift bags, or set them out as a conversation starter at parties.

Best for: Party hosts, teachers, and anyone looking for unique holiday treats

7. Matilde Vicenzi Roma Cookie Gift Tin

Matilde Vicenzi Roma Cookie Gift Tin [click to view…]

Italy meets Christmas with this stunning assortment of authentic Italian pastries and cookies. The decorative tin features panoramic views of Rome, making it a gift that’s beautiful before you even open it.

Inside the tin:

8 different varieties of Italian pastries
Puff pastry filled with chocolate cream
Puff pastry with milk cream filling
Chocolate chip cookies
Shortbread with chocolate chips
Fine decorated pastries

This is a family-run company that’s been perfecting Italian pastries since 1905. Each pastry is individually wrapped in trays to preserve freshness. The cream-filled puff pastries are particularly impressive—light, flaky, and filled with smooth cream that complements morning coffee perfectly.

Best for: Coffee and tea lovers, Italian pastry enthusiasts, and sophisticated gifting

8. Stauffer’s Holiday Shortbread Cookies

STAUFFERS Holiday Shortbread Cookies [click to view…]

These classic shortbread cookies bring nostalgia and simplicity to your holiday spread. With traditional Christmas shapes decorated with festive sparkles, they’re what many of us remember from childhood holiday gatherings.

The basics:

Star, tree, and wreath shapes
Red and green sparkles
No high fructose corn syrup
Made in USA
Kosher certified

At only 150 calories per serving, these cookies let you indulge without the guilt. The shortbread is buttery and crumbly with just the right amount of sweetness. They’re perfect for decorating charcuterie boards or enjoying with a glass of milk.

Best for: Traditional families, health-conscious snackers, and those on a budget

9. Barnett’s Biscotti Christmas Gift (24-Count)

Barnetts Christmas Cookie Gifts Box [click to view…]

Authentic Italian biscotti gets a holiday makeover with this impressive gift box. You receive 24 hand-dipped biscotti in 6 decadent flavors.

The lineup:

Chocolate Craisin
Chocolate Chip
Caramel Chip
Nut Crunch
Almond Crunch
Cookie Crunch

Each biscotti is hand-dipped in premium Belgian dark or milk chocolate and decorated with toppings. The twice-baked Italian cookies are crunchy and perfect for dunking in coffee, tea, or hot chocolate. They’re Kosher certified and non-dairy, making them suitable for various dietary needs.

The clear gift box with ribbon makes them gift-ready straight out of the package. No wrapping paper needed.

Best for: Coffee lovers, biscotti fans, and those with dairy restrictions

10. Barnett’s Chocolate Cookies & Biscotti Tower

Barnetts Christmas Holiday Cookies Gift Basket [click to view…]

This tower takes holiday gifting to the next level. You get both biscotti and chocolate-covered sandwich cookies in one impressive package.

What’s included:

12 gourmet biscotti in 6 flavors
12 artfully decorated chocolate-covered sandwich cookies
Premium natural ingredients
Tower gift box with ribbon

The combination gives you variety and visual impact. The biscotti offers that satisfying crunch, while the chocolate-covered cookies provide soft, indulgent bites. Flavors include Chocolate Craisin, Caramel Chocolate Chip, Nut Crunch, Cookie Crunch, Dark Drizzle, Peppermint, and Coconut Blend.

This is the gift that makes recipients wonder how much you spent (even though it’s surprisingly affordable).

Best for: Corporate gifts, impressive family gifts, and cookie variety lovers

Quick Comparison Guide

How to Choose the Right Christmas Cookies

Consider your audience:

Kids prefer sweeter, softer cookies like David’s or Cheryl’s
Adults appreciate gourmet options like Michel & Augustin or Matilde Vicenzi
Mixed groups do well with variety packs

Think about dietary restrictions:

Kosher options: David’s, Stauffer’s, Barnett’s
Non-dairy: Barnett’s biscotti
Nut-free: Fortune Cookies, most traditional sugar cookies

Storage matters:

Individually wrapped cookies stay fresh longer
Tin packaging protects cookies better than boxes
Check shelf life if buying in advance

Gifting tips:

Decorative tins can be reused (adds value)
Clear gift boxes showcase the cookies beautifully
Consider shipping time if ordering for specific dates

Final Thoughts

You don’t need to spend hours in the kitchen to serve memorable Christmas cookies this year. Each of these 10 options delivers bakery-quality results with zero baking stress.

For everyday snacking and family gatherings, grab David’s Cookies or Stauffer’s. When you need to impress guests or give meaningful gifts, reach for Matilde Vicenzi or Barnett’s tower. And if you want something truly unique, those Christmas Fortune Cookies will be the hit of your party.

All of these cookies are available on Amazon with fast shipping, so you can have them on your doorstep in days. Order now to ensure they arrive in time for your holiday celebrations.

Ready to stock your cookie jar? Click any link above to order your favorites and make this Christmas season a little bit sweeter—without the baking marathon.